Sunday, October 12, 2008


Document Design Matters

A few months ago I wrote about an article titled "XML Fever" that I’d written with my Berkeley ISchool colleague Erik Wilde. We’ve just published another article together called "Document Design Matters" that appears in the October 2008 Communications of the ACM.

We chose the title before we wrote the paper, and under Erik’s forceful leadership of our collaboration the paper evolved in a direction that makes the title less appropriate than it would be if I had been smart enough to be the first author. It would be more apt to title it "Metamodels Matter" but that wouldn’t sound as clever and "metamodel" would probably scare a lot of people away.

Here’s an abbreviated abstract of the paper:

The classical approach to the data aspect of system design distinguishes conceptual, logical, and physical models. Models of each type or level are governed by metamodels that specify the kinds of concepts and constraints that can be used by each model; in most cases metamodels are accompanied by languages for describing models...

In this modeling methodology, there is a single hierarchy of models that rests on the assumption that one data model spans all modeling levels and applies to all the applications in some domain. The one true model approach assumes homogeneity, but this does not work very well for the Web…

Instead of being governed by one true model used by everyone, the underlying assumption of top-down design, Web data and services evolve in an uncoordinated fashion. As a result, a fundamental challenge with Web data and services is matching and mapping local and often partial models that not only are different models of the same application domain, but also differ, implicitly or explicitly, in their associated metamodels.

Wilde and I distinguish the native or "system" data model used by an application or web service from the "exchange" model created when it interacts with another one. Exchange models are most often implemented in XML, and this can cause problems because the tree-based XML metamodel isn’t entirely compatible with the graph-based metamodels of RDF or E-R system models. The solution is probably an XML-oriented conceptual modeling language, but we only sketch what one would have to be like in this short paper.

The citation for this article is Erik Wilde and Robert J. Glushko. Document Design Matters. Communications of the ACM, 51(10):43-49, October 2008.

But you need access to the ACM digital library to find the official version, so we’ve posted (with ACM permission) an "author’s pre-print version" .

-Bob Glushko

u r blog Is very nice
There is a lot of competition in outsourcing software development, as there are many firms across the globe catering to clients looking for outsourcing their work. What is good is that the takers can choose the best from the lot.
Its really nice to read about the abstract of the paper.I agree with you that metamodel in title would have scared a lot of prospective readers away.
Well said..Document design matters. I accede with you. Documentation plays major role in well understanding of things either it is any coding or something else...
I have stumbled upon your blog and found it to be very useful! Many thanks for this post and hope you have a good one, Cheers! Socialfuel, Houston Web Design agency specializing in new media design services.
Its nice to know about the Document design. Certainly , Document design play an important role for understanding any document completely and timely. In last, I would love to say you thanks for such a informative post.
There are many interesting information included and i can easily understand all given information.I post something on my blog to post something, or wait to post something worth saying. Keep update more information....

Digital marketing company in Chennai
Writing a phrase paper can be an pleasant activity if it is dealt with treatment and the writer is not scared of it. When the proper custom writing service is chosen, creating the right term paper isn't significantly of an issue. Creating phrase papers gets relatively easier if the perfect topic is picked using the above ideas.
Grateful to check out your website, I seem to be ahead to more excellent sites and I wish that you wrote more informative post for us. Well done work.
SEO Company in Chennai

I am very happy when read this blog post because blog post written in good manner and write on good topic. Thanks for sharing valuable information.
Bangalore Web Designing Company, Web Development Company Bangalore

Its very Wonder full blog.I found some knowledge full information in the blog. thanks for sharing valuable.
UI Designing Company in Bangalore, Web Application Development Companies in Bangalore

Good work…unique site and interesting too… keep it up…looking forward for more updates.Good luck to all of you and thanks so much for your hard-work.
asi legal bangalore, asi legal,asi legal kochin,Shahul hameed

I would like to share the free download link of the attractive and useful january calendar 2019
Really a great post. Appreciate the effort in educating us. We are also same service provides in Bangalore.
Web Design Company in Bangalore
Website Designers in Bangalore
Website Development Company in Bangalore
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?